News 16th September 2026

Open by default should remain the rule, UK OGN tells government

by Guest

The UK Open Government Network (UK OGN) has submitted evidence to the government’s call for evidence on the marginal cost restriction on public sector data reuse. It argues that open access should remain the presumption for public data and that charging above marginal cost should be a narrow, evidenced exception.

The call for evidence, which closed on 8 September, asked whether public bodies should be able to charge more than marginal cost for reusing data currently made available free under the Re-Use of Public Sector Information Regulations 2015. The government says greater flexibility to charge could generate revenue for investment in data infrastructure and public services.

UK OGN’s response, agreed by the Network’s Steering Committee, accepts the underlying problem. Maintaining high-quality public data costs money, and there is a reasonable case for charging where a public body provides genuinely additional commercial products and services. But it challenges the assumption that charging for the underlying data is the way to solve it.

“Public data is not simply an asset on a departmental balance sheet,” said Kevin Keith, Chair of the UK Open Government Network. “Its value is realised when researchers analyse it, journalists interrogate it, public bodies combine it to improve services, and citizens use it to understand decisions that affect them. We are not arguing that government should never charge for anything built on public data. We are arguing that open by default should remain the rule, and that the burden of proof sits with those who want to change it.”

The intervention comes as the UK prepares to become lead government co-chair of the Open Government Partnership on 1 October. UK OGN argues that any significant departure from open-by-default policy should therefore be supported by clear evidence and developed through an open process.

The response makes three central points. First, that the commercial value of public data does not establish that charging for it maximises public value, and that the relevant test is net public value rather than departmental revenue. Second, that nothing in the call for evidence guarantees revenue would be additional rather than simply displacing core funding, and that removing the marginal cost restriction could, through the full cost recovery default in Managing Public Money, turn permission to charge into an expectation of it.

Third, UK OGN points to the Environment Agency’s 2014 decision to open its flood-risk data as a relevant precedent. At the time, government recognised that opening the data created funding and revenue implications but chose to support the move to open provision rather than preserve charging.

The submission also warns that wider charging risks handing the best-resourced technology companies preferential access to authoritative public data at a moment when it is becoming a valuable input to AI systems, and that this should be treated as a competition and growth question as much as an access one.

“The organisations that get the most out of public data are often the ones least able to pay for it,” said Julian Tait, Chief Executive of Open Data Manchester and a member of the UK OGN Steering Committee. “Community groups, small charities, local newsrooms, civic technologists. A licence fee that a large company would not notice can be the difference between a project happening and not happening. And in our experience the real barrier to reuse is rarely the price. It is data that cannot be found, cannot be joined up, or has not been properly maintained. Charging does not fix any of that.”

UK OGN has asked government to publish the responses it receives, along with a summary of the evidence and an explanation of how it has shaped any subsequent proposals.

The full response is available here and below:

– link